Skip to main content
CompareTiers
Auto-generated comparison. Editorial verdict in progress.
Email Marketing

Buttondown vs Mailtrap: Pricing Comparison 2026

Side-by-side pricing comparison of Buttondown and Mailtrap. See all plans, features, and costs at a glance.

Bottom line: Both Buttondown and Mailtrap offer free plans. Buttondown has 2 pricing tiers while Mailtrap has 4.

Last updated: September 7, 2026

Data compiled by Arthur Jacquemin
Updated September 7, 2026
Try Buttondown freeTry Mailtrap freePrice updated 3d ago
Best Value

Mailtrap - Mailtrap offers a free plan, offers 4 tiers vs 2.

Buttondown vs Mailtrap: Quick Pricing Facts

FeatureButtondownMailtrap
Starting PriceCustom pricing$15/mo
Number of Plans24
Free TierYesYes
Pricing Modelusage-basedusage-based
Annual DiscountN/AN/A

Buttondown and Mailtrap are both priced at Custom pricing, making them equally accessible Email Marketing tools. Together they offer 6 pricing plans with 31 features compared, so the best choice comes down to which features match your needs.

Both tools offer free plans, making them accessible for teams on a budget.

Review the detailed tier-by-tier comparison above to see exactly which features are included at each price point and find the best fit for your Email Marketing needs.

Pricing Plans
Buttondown
Buttondown
Try free
Mailtrap
Mailtrap
Try free
Tier 1
Free
$0/monthCheapest
Includes
  • Rich text or markdown editor
  • Send from a custom domain
  • Hosted newsletter archives
  • Privacy-first
Start with Free
Free
$0/monthCheapest
Includes
  • 1 user
  • 3 days of email logs
  • 1 domain
  • 150 emails/day
Start with Free
Tier 2
Paid Add-ons
Custom pricing
Includes
  • Tagging & segmentation (+$9/month)
  • Paid subscriptions (+$9/month)
  • Comments and surveys (+$9/month)
  • Analytics (+$9/month)
  • RSS-to-email support (+$9/month)
  • Email attachments (+$9/month)
  • Archives on a custom domain (+$29/month)
  • Multiple newsletters (+$29/month)
  • Automations (+$29/month)
  • Whitelabeling (+$79/month)
  • Teams (+$79/month)
Start with Paid Add-ons
Basic
$15/monthCheapest
Includes
  • 3 users
  • 5 days of email logs
  • 5 domains
  • No dedicated IP
Start with Basic
Tier 3
-
BusinessPopular
$85/monthCheapest
Includes
  • 100 users
  • 15 days of email logs
  • 100 domains
  • Dedicated IP
Start with Business
Tier 4
-
Enterprise
$750/monthCheapest
Includes
  • 30 days of email logs
  • Priority support
  • Custom contracts
  • Enterprise billing
Start with Enterprise

← Swipe to compare plans →

Ready to get started? Try either tool free — no credit card required.

Try Buttondown freeFree plan availableTry Mailtrap freeFree plan available
Find the best deal for your team
Answer 2 quick questions and we'll help you choose the right plan

Buttondown

Minimal newsletter tool for writers and indie publishers

View all Buttondown plans

Mailtrap

Email delivery and testing platform for developers with sending API, SMTP, and email sandbox

View all Mailtrap plans

Frequently Asked Questions: Buttondown vs Mailtrap

How many pricing plans does Buttondown have vs Mailtrap?
Buttondown offers 2 pricing plans, while Mailtrap offers 4 plans. More plans typically means more flexibility to match your exact needs and budget.
Does Buttondown or Mailtrap offer a free plan?
Yes, both Buttondown and Mailtrap offer free plans. Compare the feature limits of each free tier to see which better fits your use case before upgrading.
What is the most popular Mailtrap plan?
The Business plan is Mailtrap's most popular tier, priced at $85/mo. Key features include 100 users, 15 days of email logs, 100 domains.
Does Buttondown or Mailtrap offer custom enterprise pricing?
Buttondown offers a custom-priced enterprise tier for larger teams. Mailtrap lists all its pricing publicly.
How do Buttondown and Mailtrap compare for Email Marketing?
Both Buttondown and Mailtrap are Email Marketing tools. Buttondown offers 2 plans starting at Custom pricing, while Mailtrap offers 4 plans starting at $15/mo. Review the feature breakdowns above to see which better fits your Email Marketing needs.
AI Recommendations

Sources

  1. Buttondown Official Pricing- Vendor pricing page
  2. Mailtrap Official Pricing- Vendor pricing page

Related Articles

Best Email Marketing for Agencies (2026)

Compare email marketing pricing for agencies: ActiveCampaign ($15/mo), Amazon SES ($0/mo), AWeber ($12.50/mo). Hand-picked tools that fit teams of 10-50 people.

Best Email Marketing for Enterprise (2026)

Compare email marketing pricing for enterprise: ActiveCampaign ($15/mo), Amazon SES ($0/mo), AWeber ($12.50/mo). Hand-picked tools that fit teams of 100+ peo...

Best Email Marketing for Small Teams (2026)

Compare email marketing pricing for small teams: ActiveCampaign ($15/mo), Amazon SES ($0/mo), AWeber ($12.50/mo). Hand-picked tools that fit teams of 2-10 pe...

Track Price Changes

Get notified when pricing changes for these tools.

See all Buttondown alternativesSee all Mailtrap alternativesEmail MarketingCompare more tools